Letting the Air Out
posted by Danielle Citron
The NSA and the rest of our surveillance state apparatus is shrouded in secrecy. As captured in Frank Pasquale’s superb forthcoming book, governmental surveillance is a black box. Gag orders prevent Internet companies from talking about their participation in PRISM; nearly everything revealing is classified; the Executive Branch is telling us half truths or no truths. To counter massive governmental overreach, Bradley Manning, Edward Snowden, and others have exposed some sunlight on our surveillance state. That sunlight isn’t coming from those who are betraying the country, but those who are trying to save it, at least that’s what many registered voters think. According to a Quinnipiac poll released today, American voters say “55 – 34 percent” that NSA consultant Edward Snowden is a “whistleblower rather than a traitor.” According to the assistant director of the Quinnipiac University Polling Institute, “Most American voters think positively of Edward Snowden,” at least they did before he accepted asylum in Russia. From July 28 to July 31, 1,468 registered voters were surveyed on the phone. These sorts of leaks seem inevitable, at least culturally given our so-called commitment to openness and transparency. The leakers/whistleblowers are trying to nudge the Executive Branch to honor its commitments to the Fourth Amendment, the sentiments of the Church Report, and the Administration’s 2009 Openness and Transparency memo. Let’s see if letting the air out moves us closer to the kind of country we say we are.
H/T: Yale ISP’s Christina Spiesel for the Quinnipiac Poll