“Moksha”, the “cognitive enhancer” or rather enthoegen used in Huxley’s Island was a fictional psychopharmacological agent, but most likely a psychedelic used ceremonially during rituals. This is very different from how most people would conceptualize the use of a drug. The most salient notion is that a “cognitive enhancer” would be used on a daily basis to boost productivity. Aderall comes to mind- a legal amphetamine used for its “cognitive enhancing” properties by 25% of students surveyed in 119 highly competitive colleges in the US.

My understanding of the “moksha medicine” was that it was used for spiritual/religious purposes on an infrequent basis. Perhaps it could be likened to a form of spiritual upkeep. Maybe it was used even less often, reserved for important rites of passage. Regardless, I do not think it should be confused with the notions of “cognitive enhancers” or “dullers”. And if one is to make such a comparison, it needs to be qualified.

I sincerely agree with Dr. Chatterjee and Martha Nussbaum.

With respect,

TheMonochromaticKnight

Cures for resentment, envy, or union-organizing may also serve to enhance workplace efficiency.

I am glad we agree on something: removal of unions enhances workplace efficiency.