The New Identification: The FBI’s Biometric Database
posted by Daniel Solove
From CNN:
The FBI is gearing up to create a massive computer database of people’s physical characteristics, all part of an effort the bureau says to better identify criminals and terrorists.
But it’s an issue that raises major privacy concerns — what one civil liberties expert says should concern all Americans.
The bureau is expected to announce in coming days the awarding of a $1 billion, 10-year contract to help create the database that will compile an array of biometric information — from palm prints to eye scans.
Kimberly Del Greco, the FBI’s Biometric Services section chief, said adding to the database is “important to protect the borders to keep the terrorists out, protect our citizens, our neighbors, our children so they can have good jobs, and have a safe country to live in.”
But it’s unnerving to privacy experts.
“It’s the beginning of the surveillance society where you can be tracked anywhere, any time and all your movements, and eventually all your activities will be tracked and noted and correlated,” said Barry Steinhardt, director of the American Civil Liberties Union’s Technology and Liberty Project.
The FBI already has 55 million sets of fingerprints on file. In coming years, the bureau wants to compare palm prints, scars and tattoos, iris eye patterns, and facial shapes. The idea is to combine various pieces of biometric information to positively identify a potential suspect.
I am not one who believes that biometric identification is inherently bad, but the problem is that we don’t have the appropriate legal architecture in place to use it responsibly. For example, data security is woeful — whether it be government entities or private sector companies — and the law has not effectively grappled with this problem yet. As we move toward biometric identification, what if that data falls into the wrong hands? It’s one thing for one’s Social Security number to be leaked, a number which a person can change with a lot of bureaucratic hassle. But people can’t change their eyes or other biometric characteristics. All this makes a recipe for disaster. What are the odds that biometric information will actually be kept secure? My guess, especially given the massive number of data security breaches over the past few years, is that there will be some big leaks of biometric information in the future. I can see the data security breach notification letters already:
Dear John Doe:
We regret to inform you that your biometric data, including eye scan, fingerprint, DNA, and other information, have been leaked. An employee took it home on a laptop and that computer was stolen by a band of identity thieves. Your information might now be used for all sorts of illicit purposes, and you may find yourself suddenly arrested, deported, or sent to Guantanamo based on something the thief may have done with your data. There’s no credit monitoring or freeze or similar measure you can use to protect yourself. We suggest that you change your eyes, fingerprints, and DNA. Otherwise, all we can say is that we’re really sorry, and we’ll be sure to be more careful in the future. Of course, although we want you to have a lot of anxiety about all the dangers and risks we’ve exposed you to, we’re not foolish enough to admit you’ve been harmed, and if you sue us, we’ll be sure to insist adamantly that you weren’t ever harmed at all.
An additional problem is that there currently is not a good regulatory system in place to guard against abuses in the system or to provide oversight. How long can the data be stored? How broadly should it be collected? According to the article, “[t]he FBI says it will protect all this personal data and only collect information on criminals and those seeking sensitive jobs.” But there’s nothing stopping the FBI in the future from expanding the database at its own discretion. Who will ensure the accuracy of the data? Right now, data maintained by government agencies is protected by the Privacy Act of 1974, 5 U.S.C. § 552a, but this law has proven to be very ineffective at maintaining control over how government agencies collect, maintain, and use personal information.
February 4, 2008 at 1:36 pm
Posted in: Privacy, Privacy (Law Enforcement), Privacy (National Security)
Print This Post
Responses (14)
N - February 4, 2008 at 3:52 pm
Our only hope is that Ron Paul is elected President. He knows what’s going on and refuses to let it happen without a fight!
http://www.ronpaul2008.com
VOTE
RON PAUL!
Kevin Bouche - February 4, 2008 at 4:46 pm
Look, I don’t see a problem when they’re doing it for national security. I mean what is the major “invasion of privacy” people constantly refer to? In my opinion, I want people that need to be locked up, for that to happen ASAP to make this country safer. The idea is that no one trusts anyone anymore. By the way, to the previous poster, how does a presidential candidate have anything to do with this strict issue? People change once they get into the political sector; moreover, the White House.
KC in NC - February 4, 2008 at 5:44 pm
George Orwell did not write 1984 as an instruction manual he wrote a novel. The FBI has made some very serious mistakes with horrific consequences. Furthermore the Feds could not find their own rear ends unless they were pointed out to them. Computers are not foolproof or tamper-proof. Spoon feeding this bull feces to a bunch of sheep who believe this country can be made safer is just that – crap. It has already been PROVEN face recognition software only works about half the time and sometimes less than 10% of the time. What’s next – implanting microchips in our brains at birth so they can monitor our thoughts. There is no such thing as safety anywhere and to broker this fallacy is a joke but unfortunately people will follow right along (can anyone say baaaaa baaaa?)with this delusional idea. Big brother is already out of control and has no control over the things it should have control over such as pedophiles and internet kiddie porn. We have too many other problems in this country that need to be addressed,(homelessness, health care, etc, etc, etc.) and a multi-billion dollar program that is a complete invasion of privacy is not one of our top priorities.
Kevin Bouche - February 4, 2008 at 10:56 pm
Okay look, the 1984 refrences are just annoying anymore. If you’re going to argue a point, at least dignify a response with a real analogy, not just a bunch of improper remarks. Plus, this is an issue that needs to be fine tuned before ever being released or even tested. People are so damn concerned with privacy regarding statements like this article, but yet this isn’t a full invasion of privacy, it’s protection and analysis to prevent dangerous criminals from being on the street that have warrants, or catch a person that has completely gone off the map. Don’t just shoot something down in the development stage when it’s not being implemented yet. All the hippies and people that are just so upset about a country that wants to take security measures can just leave the states and find a new home. Don’t wine about the current situation because of a novel written how many years ago? Orwell didn’t exactly try to predict anything, he just wanted people to be alert and aware.
Landseer - August 20, 2008 at 4:06 am
Farming for wow gold (world of warcraft gold) isn’t easy, but you can buy cheap wow gold, wow power leveling on sale. Buy wow gold here, we sell cheap world of warcraft gold. Buy wow gold age of conan goldage of conan goldage of conan goldaoc goldaoc goldaoc goldnow,I think you will have your pleasure.We have revolutionized the exchange of money to wow gold with fast delivery.Purchase world of warcraft gold online and world of warcraft gold power up your character to the next level.Welcome to our website about world of warcraft gold,delivery in 24 hours,7/24 service.
Landseer - August 20, 2008 at 4:13 am
Unaware of Sargeras’ mission to undo their countless works, the Titans continued to move from world to world, shaping and ordering each planet as they saw fit. Along their journey they happened upon a small world that its inhabitants would later name Azeroth. As the Titans made their way across the primordial landscape, they encountered a number of hostilewow goldworld of warcraft goldbuy wow goldcheap wow goldwow power levelingwow powerlevelingwow goldworld of warcraft goldbuy wow goldcheap wow goldwow power levelingwow powerlevelingwow goldworld of warcraft goldbuy wow goldcheap wow goldwow power levelingwow powerleveling elemental beings. These elementals, who worshipped a race of unfathomably evil beings known only as the Old Gods, vowed to drive the Titans back and keep their world inviolate from the invaders’ metallic touch. The Pantheon, disturbed byage conan goldage conan goldbuy ffxi gilbuy ffxi gilbuy ffxi gil the Old Gods’ penchant for evil, waged war upon the elementals and their dark masters. The Old Gods’ armies were led by the most powerful elemental lieutenants: Ragnaros the Firelord, Therazane the Stonemother, Al’Akir the Windlord, and Neptulon the Tidehunter. Their chaotic forces raged across the face of the world and clashed with the colossal Titans. Though the elementals were powerful beyond mortal comprehension, their combined forces could not stop the mighty everquest 2 goldeq2 plateverquest 2 goldeq2 plateverquest 2 goldeq2 platage of conan goldaoc goldaoc power levelingage of conan power levelingage conan goldaoc levelingffxi gilfinal fantasy xi gilmaple story mesosmaplestory mesosmaplestory mesolotro goldlotr goldlord of the ring goldTitans. One by one, the elemental lords fell, and their forces dispersed. The Pantheon shattered the Old Gods’ citadels and chained the five evil gods far beneath the surface of the world. Without the Old Gods’ power to keep their raging spirits bound to the physical world,ffxi gilfinal fantasy xi gilmaple story mesosmaplestory mesosmaplestory mesolotro goldlotr goldlord of the ring goldlotro goldlotr goldlord of the ring goldmaple story mesosmaplestory mesosmaplestory mesoffxi gilfinal fantasy xi gil the elementals were banished to an abyssal plane, where they would contend with one another for all eternity. With the elementals’ departure, nature calmed, and the world settled into a peaceful harmony. The Titans saw that the threat was contained and set to work. The Titans empowered a number of races runescape goldrunescape moneyrunescape goldrunescape moneyrunescape goldrunescape moneysilkroad goldbuy silkroad goldsilkroad goldbuy silkroad goldcity of villains infamycov infamy to help them fashion the world. To help them carve out the fathomless caverns beneath the earth, the Titans creat
ed the dwarf-like earthen from magical, living stone. To help them dredge out the seas and liftwow levelingwow golddofus kamaskamas dofusdofus kamaskamas dofusdofus kamaskamas dofusage of conan goldaoc power levelingage of conan power levelingaoc leveling the land from the sea floor, the Titans created the immense but gentle sea giants. For many ages the Titans moved and shaped the earth, until at last there remained one perfect continent. At the continent’s center, the Titans crafted a lake of scintillating energies. The lake, which they named the Well of Eternity, was to be the fount of life for the world. Its potentrappelz rupeerappelz goldstar wars galaxies creditsswg creditssilkroad goldsilk road goldsword of the new world vistales of pirates gold energies would nurture the bones of the world and empower life to take root in the land’s rich soil. Over time, plants, trees, monsters, and creatures of every kind began to thrive on age of conan goldage of conan goldage of conan goldaoc power levelingage of conan power levelingaoc levelingage of conan goldaoc power levelingage of conan power levelingaoc leveling the primordial continent. As twilight fell on the final day of their labors, the Titans named the continent Kalimdor: “land of eternal starlight”.
dofus - May 9, 2009 at 10:54 pm
Bon marche de Dofus Kamas
lxj - July 13, 2009 at 5:26 pm
The ring is always louboutin shoes the highlight christian louboutin shoesof every marriagechristian louboutin proposal. In factlouboutin shoes discount, it has taken louboutin shoessuch a major role louboutin shoe salethat no engagementSale christian louboutin is ever the sameBuy christian louboutin Store without itSandals Online. This popularity christian louboutin shoeshas added to christian louboutin sandals the appeal of Buy louboutin shoesthe engagement ringchristian louboutin as well as to its pricechristian louboutin. Since engagement ringschristian louboutin can be worth a lotchristian louboutin shoes, people who buy them have to christian louboutin new yorkmake an informed choice.
12Sky Silver Coins - November 12, 2009 at 2:08 am
In the game, the twelve sky Gold is important, there are many players need the 12sky gold, so sometimes if somebody want to send something, I often told them I need twelvesky Gold, so now my friends often give their more 12Sky Silver Coins for me, so now in the game I already had enough 12 sky gold.
Pirates of the Burning Sea Gold - November 18, 2009 at 7:30 pm
In the game the Pirates of the Burning Sea Gold is very useful, in the game all players need that they had more potbs money so sometimes they spend much money to buy potbs Doubloon
Sankara Velayudhan Nandakumar - January 6, 2010 at 12:41 am
criminals:This can also be compared with clubbed thumb,brain line deviating up with reference to palm print analysis in case of criminals,as a comparatorAn islaned formation of fate line with breaking laife or vital line at the same time.Requires palm print comparator in such studies
Sankara Velayudhan Nandakumar - January 6, 2010 at 12:44 am
Palm print as cerebral hologram really reveals the truth.
metin2 yang - January 27, 2010 at 12:10 am
lili
Santa Clara locksmith - April 25, 2011 at 7:20 am
I solidly imagine that the expertise supplied is highly relevant to almost everyone . Thanks a ton .
Leave a Reply