the Law, the Universe, and Everything 

Search

Concurring Opinions is a
general-interest legal blog
operated by Concurring
Opinions LLC, a Pennsylvania
Limited Liability Corporation.

Yale University Press

ad-logo5.jpg

Our Podcast

Subscribe to Law Talk

Law-Rev-Forum-2.jpg

law-rev-contents2.jpg

Law-Prof-Blog-Census.jpg

Categories

Administrative Announcements
Administrative Law
Admiralty
Advertising
Agricultural Law
Anonymity
Antitrust
Architecture
Articles and Books
Bankruptcy
Behavioral Law and Economics
Bioethics
Blogging
Book Reviews
Capital Punishment
Civil Procedure
Civil Rights
Conferences
Constitutional Law
Consumer Protection Law
Contract Law & Beyond
Corporate Law
Criminal Law
Criminal Procedure
Culture
Current Events
Cyberlaw
DRM
Economic Analysis of Law
Education
Empirical Analysis of Law
Employment Law
Environmental Law
Family Law
Feminism and Gender
First Amendment
Food
Google & Search Engines
Health Law
History of Law
Humor
Immigration
Insurance Law
Intellectual Property
International & Comparative Law
Interviews
Jurisprudence
Law and Humanities
Law and Inequality
Law and Psychology
Law Practice
Law Professor Blogger Census
Law Rev (Boston College)
Law Rev (Boston University)
Law Rev (California)
Law Rev (Chicago)
Law Rev (Columbia)
Law Rev (Cornell)
Law Rev (Duke)
Law Rev (Emory)
Law Rev (Fordham)
Law Rev (Georgetown)
Law Rev (GW)
Law Rev (Harvard)
Law Rev (Illinois)
Law Rev (Indiana)
Law Rev (Michigan)
Law Rev (Minnesota)
Law Rev (Northwestern)
Law Rev (Notre Dame)
Law Rev (NYU)
Law Rev (Penn)
Law Rev (S Cal)
Law Rev (Stanford)
Law Rev (Texas)
Law Rev (UCLA)
Law Rev (Vanderbilt)
Law Rev (Virginia)
Law Rev (Wash U)
Law Rev (Yale)
Law Rev Contents
Law Rev Forum
Law School
Law School (Hiring & Laterals)
Law School (Law Reviews)
Law School (Rankings)
Law School (Scholarship)
Law School (Teaching)
Law Student Discussions
Law Talk
Legal Ethics
Legal Theory
Media Law
Movies & Television
Philosophy of Social Science
Politics
Privacy
Privacy (Consumer Privacy)
Privacy (Electronic Surveillance)
Privacy (Gossip & Shaming)
Privacy (ID Theft)
Privacy (Law Enforcement)
Privacy (Medical)
Privacy (National Security)
Property Law
Race
Religion
Reparations
Science Fiction
Securities
Social Network Websites
Sociology of Law
Supreme Court
Tax
Teaching
Technology
Tort Law
Web 2.0
Weird
Wiki
Wills, Trusts, and Estates

Recent Comments

Casey on Law Talk: George R. R. Martin

M R Brusino on Law Talk: George R. R. Martin

Rob Hobart on Law Talk: George R. R. Martin

john on Law Talk: George R. R. Martin

Charles on Law Talk: George R. R. Martin

Stephen M (Ethesis) on Law Talk: George R. R. Martin

Boiled Leather Smallclothes on Law Talk: George R. R. Martin

Gary 7 on Law Talk: George R. R. Martin

Gary 7 on Law Talk: George R. R. Martin

Syd on Law Talk: George R. R. Martin

Archives

May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
October 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005

 

« Cornell Law Review, Volume 93 Number 1 (November 2007) | Main | Michigan Law Review, Issue 106:3 (December 2007) »

December 18, 2007

Law Talk: George R. R. Martin

posted by Dave Hoffman

gm-lochness-t.jpgIn today's episode of Law Talk, we hear from George R. R. Martin, the prolific author of the "high fantasy" series The Song of Ice and Fire. George has also been a screenwriter and Hollywood producer, an editor, a chess tournament director, a union leader, and a volunteer media director for the Cook County Legal Assistance Foundation. As I've previously written, George is a leader in the movement to bring a degree of realism to fantasy, and he has been dubbed (by Time Magazine) "The American Tolkien."

George and I talked for almost an hour, on topics ranging from the role of law in fantasy books (starting 3.5 minutes in); the limits of magic as a plot device (20 minutes in); law professor Robert Cover (22 minutes in, brought up by me, to my shame); why most fantasy novels seem to be set in merry olde england (28 minutes in); fan fiction and copyright infringement (31minutes in); how writing sci-fi is like selling music, and whether he likes Radiohead's distribution model (35 minutes in); how to keep control over your work when it is transformed into another medium (39 minutes in); and inheritance law (toward the end).

George is a fantastically interesting, well-read, thoughtful guy, and I think you will enjoy this interview quite a bit. (If you aren't a fan of the books, ignore my constant, irritating, references to characters you have never heard of.) Finally, if you want to learn more about George, visit his blog (which he says isn't one) and join the hordes of folks waiting for the next installment of the series, A Dance With Dragons, to ship.

Missed the link? Here's the interview again. Warning: it's a big file!

You can subscribe to "Law Talk" using iTunes or Feedburner. You can also visit the "Law Talk" page at the iTunes store. For previous episodes of Law Talk at Co-Op click here.

For other posts in the "Law and Hard Fantasy" Interview Series, see:


Posted by Dave Hoffman at December 18, 2007 12:26 PM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.concurringopinions.com/movabletype/mt-tb.cgi/2934.

Comments

why most fantasy novels seem to be set in merry olde england (28 minutes in)

All of the cultural accretion going back to Morte D'Arthur? Interesting question: The idea of "fantasy westerns" seems as odd to me as the idea of "gunslinging Jane Austen novels."

Posted by: Stuart Buck at December 18, 2007 12:48 PM


Stephen King's Dark Tower series was essentially a fantasy western, at least in the earlier books.

This is so amazing. Thanks for this feature.

Posted by: Amber at December 18, 2007 01:13 PM


I just have a question for George. Have you picked anybody to finish the Song of Ice and Fire, and how much shelving will it take? :)

Recommendation: Daniel Abraham's A Shadow in Summer

Posted by: Alan Kellogg at December 18, 2007 07:50 PM


George R.R. has become the most hated man in my literary Universe.
I bought the first three installments of "The Song of Fire & Ice" as Amazon alluded to it as a trilogy. Then waited several years for book four, which, of course, turned out to be book 3 and a half. Several years later, still waiting for the conclusion to book four.
Of course, as I'm a senior citizen, I've given up any hope of reading the final denounment book of the series. In fact, George not being a "spring chicken", if he keeps screwing around instead of writing the final volumes of the series he'll also have passed on prior to the ending.
I blame George Bush!

Posted by: Mike at December 18, 2007 09:00 PM


If you read his blog or whatever he wants to call it, you'll find him to be a man filled with hatred and an almost fatal case of BDS.

Posted by: ob1 at December 18, 2007 09:17 PM


I had the opportunity to attend a reading George performed from A Game of Thrones at Necronomicon in 1994 (he read Chapters 1 and 3). So I have been waiting extra long for him to get the story finished. But as long as he keeps working at it, I am content.

Posted by: Michael Pate at December 18, 2007 10:19 PM


I don't know what ob1 is blathering about above. The blog is actually intelligent and interesting. Maybe he just doesn't like George's choice of football teams or something.

Posted by: dischord at December 18, 2007 10:56 PM


Where is the love for my man George!?!? Time Magazine calls him "The American Tolkien" and for good reason.

I'm waiting with baited breath for the next book too but its because his books are so damn good that we are all impatient for them to come out.

It always surprises me how quickly people go from liking the guy's work to anger at it not being done fast enough.

Posted by: Michael Natale at December 19, 2007 09:02 AM


Agreed! George R.R. Martin is a fantastic author and storyteller. It takes time to write a good book, not to mention a huge series of excellent books. Do you think JRR Tolkien finished LOTR in 5 years? No...he worked on it for over 15 years, and the entire series was as long as just one of GRRM's books.

I'd rather have him take 20 years to finish the series and produce something legendary, than to hurry through the books to please a few thousand impatient fans and produce something mediocre that nobody will remember in 30 years.

Martin is the best, hands down.

Posted by: Aaron W. at December 19, 2007 09:28 AM


i must repeat: grrm is the best.
my only withdrow is that now all other fantasy seems nothing comperd to asoiaf. but it's worth it.

Posted by: etay at December 19, 2007 01:47 PM


i must repeat: grrm is the best.
my only withdrow is that now all other fantasy seems nothing comperd to asoiaf. but it's worth it.

Posted by: etay at December 19, 2007 01:47 PM


i must repeat: grrm is the best.
my only withdrow is that now all other fantasy seems nothing comperd to asoiaf. but it's worth it.

Posted by: etay at December 19, 2007 01:47 PM


i must repeat: grrm is the best.
my only withdrow is that now all other fantasy seems nothing comperd to asoiaf. but it's worth it.

Posted by: etay at December 19, 2007 01:47 PM


Interesting interview. I just picked up A Game of Thrones yesterday and I am 100 pages into it. It's excellent so far... very different from my expectations.

Posted by: Spinnray at December 19, 2007 07:01 PM


asoiaf is the best fiction ever produced, my complaint as an addict is that i have no idea when i will get my next fix, will it be years?

Posted by: andrew at December 19, 2007 07:03 PM


Thanks for the great world you have written for us Mr. Martin. I wish every one would stop complaining. Dont you guys know. Every time some one complains a Stark is killed. Shhhhhh!

Posted by: mjgrass at December 20, 2007 01:25 AM


The only book(s) that came close to GRRM's series is David Durham's Acacia...durham seems, to me at least, to be bit darker--but his playing around with moral choices (rather than render such a vivid, and often disheartening, picture of humanity like GRRM) gives you hope, if not for the characters in the book, but for the rest of us. I love both these authors. And I'm a corporate lawyer! Wonder why we all tend towards escapism...

Posted by: kvjack at December 20, 2007 11:43 AM


I think the first three books of Martin's series may be my favorite. The fourth (or 3.5) was very good by others' standards, but did not seem as exciting. I suspect it was the extra time Martin spent trying to make it perfect, although maybe he had lost the love for the series and the drive to share it.

No one knows when Martin will finish his fifth book. He cannot even make a schedule, let alone stick to it. Martin has filled his days with numerous other tasks and appears more excited about those than his series.

Martin is a former union leader and a liberal, as to be expected of union leaders and most artists. However, I have not heard much hatred of BDS on his forums (just normal obvious preference for the liberal point of view on most topics). It would be an interesting hypothesis to correlate the lack of outstanding work (or at least not quite as superior, in theory) with President Bush being elected (emotionally overwhelming poor Martin).

Posted by: Pete at December 20, 2007 02:40 PM


Pete: I think the fourth book suffered because so many of the major characters (Daenerys and Jon particularly) were off-stage and their stories will be picked up in volume 5.

Posted by: Syd at December 20, 2007 11:02 PM


I can well understand the obsessive drive to perfection. It's what makes for excellence. it also drives "normal" people nuts,,,Fortunately, I'm not normal,,,

I do hope George finishes Ice and Fire before I croak(64 and diabetic), but if not, I guess I'll just have to reincarnate and read it as a historical document.

Ah,the Law! That which makes it possible for civilization to accomplish the impossible, ie, build really BIG projects.

Posted by: Gary 7 at December 21, 2007 10:56 AM


I can well understand the obsessive drive to perfection. It's what makes for excellence. it also drives "normal" people nuts,,,Fortunately, I'm not normal,,,

I do hope George finishes Ice and Fire before I croak(64 and diabetic), but if not, I guess I'll just have to reincarnate and read it as a historical document.

Ah,the Law! That which makes it possible for civilization to accomplish the impossible, ie, build really BIG projects.

Posted by: Gary 7 at December 21, 2007 03:10 PM


Definitely the most interesting interview of Martin I've come across. The law angle made for some really interesting comments from Martin on the history/background of Westeros.

As for the haters above, if you dislike Martin's politics go read some fiction written by your stalwart conservative brethren.

Oh that's right, conservative writers/artists all suck ass. You'd be stuck with Pat Boone, Ted Nugent, Dennis Miller and those Left Behind books to entertain yourselves. I guess I understand why you need us bleedin' heart liberal commies to entertain your sorry asses.

Posted by: Boiled Leather Smallclothes at December 22, 2007 04:32 PM


Do the later books handle the concepts of scale better? The first book doesn't seem to have a tight handle on it, which made the book unpleasant for me, and I never went on to read more.

Posted by: Stephen M (Ethesis) at December 26, 2007 12:51 AM


What are you all talking about? A Feast for Crows was the best book yet. The tragedy of Jaime Lannister alone was worthy of a Hugo. The series gets better with each installment, though I'm not really looking forward to all those Danywhatever chapters...

Posted by: Charles at December 27, 2007 01:11 AM


I wasn't planning to read "a feast of crows" until the next book came out because I read that almost none of the major characters would be in it. I was however supprised at how much i enjoyed the book it turned out to be very good. Many people are to stuck on their favourite characters. They shouldn't be the characters might get killed off at any time just enjoy the great story and all the great characters in it.

Posted by: john at December 31, 2007 03:38 PM


"Oh that's right, conservative writers/artists all suck ass. You'd be stuck with Pat Boone, Ted Nugent, Dennis Miller and those Left Behind books to entertain yourselves. I guess I understand why you need us bleedin' heart liberal commies to entertain your sorry asses."

Wow, that's an astonishingly ill-informed post. Apparently you've never heard of S.M. Stirling, John Ringo, Tim Powers, David Weber... or, for that matter, J.R.R. Tolkein.

Posted by: Rob Hobart at January 3, 2008 04:40 PM


Thank you for this!

I'm currently in the design stage of my own personal fantasy-world, and this has definitely lead to questions that I may not have reached.

It also interests me greatly to hear GRRM (whom I adore) speak of the history and general design of his own world that we all love.

I would love to hear more about his world, the steps he took to design it, and things of that nature, but that's for another forum.

I do find it humorous that a few of you are in such an uproar over an authors political fervor and affiliations - I seek a fantastic story, I could care less as to what your beliefs are.

Posted by: M R Brusino at January 13, 2008 04:37 PM


I have read all the books so far and await the next. They are wonderful. And he gets better artists than Jordan gets for his Wheel of Time. I have given copies of "A Game of Thrones" to readers of all kinds and have a permanent lending out copy for people to look at (usually my friends that aren't into fantasy). I have had to replace it 3 times because either someone moved away with it(2) or lent it to someone else and had to get their own. I hope to see spinoffs of it, with other writers trying on some of the minor characters for size. I hope Martin finishes it. It is starting to have the feel of something that might not get that way....

Posted by: Casey at March 5, 2008 01:38 AM


Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)

Authors

Daniel J. Solove

Website
Understanding Privacy

Kaimipono Wenger

Website
SSRN Page

Dave Hoffman

Website
SSRN Page

Nate Oman

Website
SSRN Page

Frank Pasquale

Website
SSRN Page

Deven Desai

Website
SSRN Page


Guests

William Birdthistle
Elaine Chiu
David Fontana
James Grimmelmann
Dan Kahan
Sam Kamin
Anita S. Krishnakumar
William McGeveran
Michael O'Shea






ad-logo3.jpg

blawg100_winner2.jpg

Previous Guests

Michael Abramowicz
Michelle Adams
Robert Ahdieh
Michelle Anderson
Laura Appleman
Francesca Bignami
Jeremy Blumenthal
Bruce Boyden
Donald Braman
Al Brophy
Bill Burke-White
Scott Burris
Anupam Chander
Miriam Cherry
Jack Chin
Jennifer Collins
Allison Danner
Brannon Denning
Deven Desai
Mike Dimino
Christine Haight Farley
Kim Ferzan
Dan Filler
Amanda Frost
Timothy Glynn
Rachel Godsil
Eric Goldman
Craig Green
Jeffrey Harrison
Erica Hashimoto
Laura Heymann
Christine Hurt
Heidi Kitrosser
Adam Kolber
Russell Korobkin
Anita S. Krishnakumar
Greg Lastowka
Joseph Liu
Solangel Maldonado
Jason Mazzone
William McGeveran
Salil Mehra
Carrie Menkel-Meadow
Scott Moss
Eric Muller
Jaya Ramji-Nogales
Elizabeth Nowicki
Paul Ohm
Michael O'Shea
Rafael Pardo
Marcy Peek
Eduardo Peñalver
Neil RIchards
Lori Ringhand
Alice Ristroph
Paul Secunda
Peter Smith
Charles Sullivan
Rick Swedloff
Steph Tai
Robert Tsai
Steve Vladeck
Sarah Waldeck
Melissa Waters
Alfred Yen
David Zaring
Timothy Zick
Jonathan Zittrain

Blogroll

Above the Law
ACS Blog
Althouse
Balkinization
Becker-Posner Blog
Beltway Blogroll
BlackProf
BoingBoing
Chicago Law Faculty Blog
Conglomerate
Convictions
CrimLaw
Crime & Federalism
CrimProf Blog
Crooked Timber
Discourse.net
Dorf on Law
Election Law
Emergent Chaos
Feminist Law Profs
43(B)log
Freakonomics Blog
Freedom to Tinker
Google Blogoscoped
How Appealing
Ideoblog
Info/Law
Instapundit.com
JD2B.com
Juris Novus
Jurisdynamics
Law and Letters
Legal Profession Blog
Legal Theory Blog
Legal Times Blog
Leiter Reports
Brian Leiter's Law School Reports
Lessig Blog
Madisonian
Mirror of Justice
National Security Advisors
Opinio Juris
Point of Law
Political Theory Daily Review
PrawfsBlawg
ProfessorBainbridge.com
Property Prof
Red Tape Chronicles
The Right Coast
Schneier on Security
SCOTUSBlog
Security Dilemmas
Sentencing Law and Policy
Simple Justice
Sivacracy.net
The Situationist
Susan Crawford
TalkLeft
Talking Points Memo
TaxProf Blog
Tech & Marketing Law
Truth on the Market
Volokh Conspiracy
WorkPlace Prof Blog
WSJ Law Blog
Wonkette
The Yin Blog

Pajamas Media BlogRoll Member