« An Obvious Idea | Main | Discrimination Law Going to the Dogs? »
May 15, 2006
If Pigs Had Wings
The Sunday New York Times has a story on people invoking the service animal protections of the Americans with Disabilities Act to bring animals that provide them with emotional support on airplanes and in to restaurants and other normally human-only settings.
In 2003 the Department of Transportation issued an administrative opinion that animals used to aid people with emotional ailments like depression or anxiety should be given the same access and privileges as animals helping people with physical disabilities like blindness or deafness.
Unsure of just what the law requires and fearful of being sued, airlines, presented with a letter from a medical professional attesting to an animal's function, have made available cabin space for emotionally supportive goats, ducks, monkeys and miniature horses--in addition to more pedestrian cats and dogs. The gist of the Times article is that, on the one hand, lots of people seem to really need their animals around them at all times. On the other hand, an emotional supportive duck seems a long way from a seeing eye dog.
Then, of course, there are the other airline passengers or restaurant diners.
Some years ago, US Air allowed a woman and her daughter who invoked the ADA to bring into first class their 250 pound potbelly pig. When they made the reservation they apparently said they had a 13 pound "service animal." For whatever reason US Air personnel at the airport decided they had to accommodate the beast.
The flying pig, seated between seats 1A and 1C, stayed quiet for most of the Seattle to Philadelphia flight, presumably providing silently its emotional support. But when the plane landed, the pig ran up the aisle, tried to enter the cockpit and then sat stubbornly in the galley until lured out with food.
No word on whether post-9/11 air marshals have training in handling disurptive farm animals aboard.
Posted by Jason Mazzone at May 15, 2006 03:23 PM
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.concurringopinions.com/movabletype/mt-tb.cgi/845.
Comments
What if I go everywhere carrying a letter from my doctor that I have a documented and crippling fear of animals? Do I get a guarantee of an animal-free plane?
If I'm being treated for extreme claustrophobia, do I get to fly on an empty plane?
When did we swtich from "reasonable accommodation" to unconditional accommodation?
Posted by: KipEsquire at May 15, 2006 05:12 PM
This story should have focused on the lawyers for the airlines (and other common carriers) who are too spineless to draw lines, not on the ADA and its unintended effects.
Posted by: David S. Cohen at May 16, 2006 12:46 PM
I want a miniature horse!
Posted by: Mikey at May 16, 2006 12:48 PM
I want in-flight bacon!
Posted by: Valkor at May 17, 2006 11:46 AM
I have claustrophobia....will they provide me a plane devoid of enclosures?
Posted by: Arlington Acid at December 21, 2006 06:21 PM
